DEADLY CHOICE | Kirkus Reviews

In Manning’s novel, a mother seeks revenge on those she blames for her daughter’s death.

Patricia is a middle-aged, single mother whose newlywed only daughter, Ashley, died after being denied a medically necessary abortion. Ashley’s husband, David, is suing Ashley’s doctor, the hospital, and the hospital’s lawyer, Brenda Phillips, who plans to run for office on a conservative, pro-life platform. Patricia plans a more drastic action: murder. But when she uses a stolen identity to become the Phillips family’s housekeeper, Brenda’s uncaring behavior toward her young children sparks Patricia’s motherly instincts, giving rise to conflicted feelings about her intentions. A second plotline involves Brenda’s high-school sweetheart, John Petersen, now a male-chauvinist religious fanatic who believes murder is justifiable to save the unborn. A third thread is devoted to Lisette “Lizzie” Vaughn, a private investigator (Lizzie and her assistant, Murphy Green, a Black, trans ex-cop, have their own complicated backstories), and a fourth follows Isabella Ramirez, a single mother with a heart condition who believes her unplanned second pregnancy could kill her (and whose wimpy ex-husband, Wyatt, has joined John’s group of radical anti-abortionists). The various strands converge when Isabella and her young daughter, Nina, go missing, and her friend Ethan calls Lizzie rather than go to the police (“A young woman should be sympathetic to the plight of a woman whose pregnancy could kill her”). The novel brings together a memorable cast of characters to highlight the potentially deadly consequences of “pro-life” activism as the narrative alternates between the points of view of Patricia, Lizzie, John, Isabella, Brenda, and others. Each character sees only part of the picture, resulting in multiple vectors of suspense that keep the reader hooked. Additionally, seeing each character’s actions through their own individual lenses provides a more nuanced consideration of the social and moral issues that drive their decisions and actions. Manning presents complicated heroes with dark sides and villains who, while they are less multi-dimensional, also have redeeming qualities. The portrayals of Lizzie and Murphy suggest they might be poised for further adventures.

Compelling characters stop at nothing to achieve their ends in this very contemporary thriller.